Wednesday, May 6, 2020
New Article Reveals the Low Down on Fsu Essay Topics 2019 and Why You Must Take Action Today
New Article Reveals the Low Down on Fsu Essay Topics 2019 and Why You Must Take Action Today The 5-Minute Rule for Fsu Essay Topics 2019 An essay format is a string of guidelines that determine the way your paper ought to be arranged. The essay format style doesn't have anything to do with the intricacy of your paper. If your essay is describing a process, like how to make a huge chocolate cake, make sure your paragraphs fall in the proper order. At our on-line provider, writing essays is a distinctive procedure that can be compared to a masterpiece creation. New Step by Step Roadmap for Fsu Essay Topics 2019 You're likely writing tons of essays for different applications, and perhaps you just need a little bit of a break from the entire process. The MLA rule book states that the paragraphs should start with leaving a half-inch space at the start. Formatting your essay is only a matter of plugging the correct information into the proper locations. Last word of advice is to as k your teacher before the last decision about this issue selection for argumentative essays. Fsu Essay Topics 2019 Secrets That No One Else Knows About The essay has to have an everlasting effect on the minds of the readers. No matter the mission of the essay, make sure you're interested in your topic. Following are a few of the suggested sociology essay topic for those students that are unable to pick a great topic for their assignment. Writing argument essay may be an art in the sense so that it requires thorough understanding of the subject, together with skill. The Ugly Side of Fsu Essay Topics 2019 If you successfully determine the objective of language essay than you ought to be sure the subject of language essay should fit in the goal. You might have to establish what you wish to write in your essay. An essay is a brief bit of writing, generally focusing on a distinct subject issue. Expository essay utilizes formal language to go over someone or something. Though the conclusion paragraph comes at the conclusion of your essay it ought not be regarded as an afterthought. No matter how you are going to wind up submitting your essay, you should draft it into a word processor. There are a lot of different essay formats that are used by writers based on the topic matter or the use of the essay. Lastly, the previous sentence of the very first paragraph of this kind of essay would state the thesis the author is attempting to prove. The rules for writing a great essay are not any different. Therefore, either you would like to learn more about how to compose an essay, or you desire some essay writing services or even in the event you would like to go through some sample essays, then just refer to WritingBest and all of your requirements will be fulfilled once possible. Essentially, thesis statement ought to be proven throughout the essay. Essay writing isn't only among the most enduring academic assignments students have been doing for d ecades, but in addition an indispensable portion of learning. While an essay is a big project, there are lots of steps a student can take which will help break down the task into manageable pieces. Despite the ample amount of substantial research materials and intelligent ideas, it may end up flawed if the student does not have effective writing skills. Writing argumentative essay is a complicated job, as it requires the presence of many skills at the exact same moment. The Ultimate Fsu Essay Topics 2019 Trick As an example, let's say if you're writing about language history essay than you might have to to incorporate all of the information concerning the history language on earth no matter any specific region while in specific language history essay, you would speak about history of the language of a specific region. A great idea may be to pick out a subject, which has a stable selection of accessible info and nonetheless sufficient room for a private research. Among the mos t prevalent issues in our world today is the matter of deforestation. Most Noticeable Fsu Essay Topics 2019 You might see college essay templates on the internet that offer guidelines about how to structure your essay and what things to say in each individual paragraph. Writing an essay at our company is completely stress-free. Writing your very first APA format essay can be a bit intimidating at first, but learning a number of the basic rules of APA style can provide help. The greatest argumentative essay writing service on the world wide web is a business that supplies good quality and very affordable help on argumentative essay and argumentative essay topics. In case you're attempting to come across high essay writing firms, look at the talked about above. The important target of essay program is to frame your upcoming work and maintain appropriate flow. As soon as you imitate the job written by somebody else and move it as your individual it's generally called plagiaris m. Among the biggest obstacles that students face when seeking to compose an outstanding essay is receiving the principal points across in a clear, logical fashion which in fact answers the established question. Up in Arms About Fsu Essay Topics 2019? Usually it's intelligent to pay slightly additional and be sure the essay will likely be excellent. Subsequently, essay was defined in various ways. The topics for argumentative essays are frequently very self-explanatory they're common understanding. Occasionally, selecting a great argumentative essay topics will be quite tough. Want to Know More About Fsu Essay Topics 2019? You see, the conventions of English essays are somewhat more formulaic than you may think and, in a variety of ways, it can be as easy as counting to five. Such essays shall have a good deal of quotations, based just on facts and laws, and show no more than the true picture of the instance. The most important use of the college essay format is to assist the readers follow main ideas on the other side of the content without stumbling upon its structure. The format of the works cited page also varies based on the fashion of citation used inside your text.
Tuesday, May 5, 2020
Diversity and Inclusion Action Plan-myassignmenthelp.com
Question: Discuss about theDiversity and Inclusion Action Plan. Answer: The lack of equity and inclusiveness at workplace has compelled the Canadian Government to introduce Equity, Diversity and Inclusion Action Plan, that has mandated that the organizations recruiting policies must be free from unconscious gender bias. As per the legislator requirement, Air Canada follows a woman inclusion strategy in its recruitment policy. In fact, the company has set example by assigning prominent roles to the women employees throughout the company, starting with the airport ramp to C-suite offices and the companys boardroom. In fact, approximately half of the employees working here are women and most importantly more than 40 % of the middle managers are women as well. The anti-gender bias and job segregation, traced in the recruitment policy of any company is highly condemnable as per the Workplace Practice and Diversity policy of Canada, and hence Air Canada has successfully incorporated the female employee recruitment and promotion policy. In fact, it is worthwhil e to mention here that the company has already hosted two "Women in Aviation" events, meant to encourage as well as inspire its each female employee to establish her own network in the workplace. Reference List: Air Canada Named one of Canada's Top Diversity Employers for the Second Consecutive Year. (2017).Newswire.ca. Retrieved 12 September 2017, from https://www.newswire.ca/news-releases/air-canada-named-one-of-canadas-top-diversity-employers-for-the-second-consecutive-year-617325383.html
Friday, April 3, 2020
The creatures free essay sample
Without competition our past would be way different from the tale that we are informed through our education. I mainly believe that conflicting ideas made me who I am. This confliction may happen in various areas HoWeVeR today I am only interested in the confliction between imprisonment and freedom . You know words that usually evokes us heaven belongs simply to things that we usually categorize under the word good. But when these characteristics uniform in history, we face with a MANiMAL which uses it magical powers as evil everything suddenly changes and now we are forced to look at things happened in history from n another perspective. So we can mention about the existence of extraterrestrials in our world in ancient times, right? I bet we can. One of the species (ALiENS) were called as Sirens and they did have a voice which poisons human by amazement. When you hear the sound once you cant keep yourself listening from listening it more which really does lead to death caused by starvation. We will write a custom essay sample on The creatures or any similar topic specifically for you Do Not WasteYour Time HIRE WRITER Only 13.90 / page They did have wings and moreover due to this physical superiority they were worshipped as if they were Gods. By the way havent you checked the definition in dictionary of this holly word. if not here it is. the one Supreme Being, the creator and ruler of the universe. As you read the definition it says that these extraterrestrials are the rulers of this humans. However can we classify power by Just looking at the physical strength of something? Personally being powerful should also consist of being emotionally strong. So are these creatures, (Sirens) really outclass humans This is a question that people have been discussing for decades and didnt reach a final result or an universally acceptable comment. Sharing emotions was way too important for communication and some even believe hat this desire was unique to our planet. Was it? According to some text from ancient civilizations these bird like angels lived in an island which was named after its own specie. SiRENlJM The creatures did kill the ones who are trying to reach them in order to communicate with them however their end was death. These creatures were frightened of us so they didnt let us to invade their land in earth. A part from heaven When we look at this it seems a bit weird because confliction of these species did create a infinite loop. Aliens were imprisoned at SiRENlJM and people were also stuck ith the remaining land in earth. So dont you also think that this limitations and imprisonment creates a part of the weaknesses for both of the side. This endless loop desperately continuous with the idea of Helping Strangers By Sacrificing your life. When sirens call for help they are killing humanity at the same time that makes things more complicated than it was used to be. Isnt it a bit selfish to ask for someone elses life in order to survive in a kind of a away game. But what can we do about it, after all arent they are still GODS in our unconscious minds
Sunday, March 8, 2020
Tiziano de Cadore essays
Tiziano de Cadore essays In Vasari's Lives of the Artists, Vasari offers us a fairly in-depth portrait of Tiziano de Cadore (most commonly and hereafter to be referred to as "Titian") both as one of the great painters of the Renaissance and as a truly great and beneficent individual. Indeed, the portrait of Titian that Vasari offers is one of a prodigiously and suprememly talented youth whose early painting went through a series of exceptionally dramatic although always impressive shifts. Indeed, many of these changes were due to his alternation tutelage, as well as the fact that, hailing from Venice, he was not initially in contact with the changes in painting then going on in Rome. Specifically, Early works of Titian betray a general ignorance of the resurgent classicism and historical study of painting then occurring in Rome, but with the arrival of some Roman-schooled painters, he adapted his style to be more in tune with the Roman one, while retaining much of the vigor and energy of the Venetian painting of his youth. Titian later traveled to Rome and found much success there, but he ultimately returned again to Venice. Indeed, his style changed yet again as he aged, but these changes only reflected Titian's amazing strength and versatility as a painter and revealed the very elements of his style and sensibilities that make us remember him even today, hundreds of years after his death. Indeed, much of the mystique surrounding Titian can be derived from his own enormous individual talent. Even as a young child he should an enormous interest in a and talent for painting, and it was these factors that convinced his father to apprentice him with the great northern painter He, seeing that the boy was much inclined to painting, put him with the famous painter Gian Bellini, under whose discipline he studied drawing, and showed himself in a short time to be endowed by nature ...
Thursday, February 20, 2020
'It is impossible to discern from the approach of the judiciary to Essay
'It is impossible to discern from the approach of the judiciary to either the question of the incidence of the burden of proof - Essay Example CJS is accountable for apprehending the criminals, penalising them for their offences, executing the orders of the court like custodial punishment, collecting fines imposed by courts, supervising the community and to rehabilitate them for stopping future crimes2. CJS evaluates its operation by employing the following five indicators namely a) bringing crimes to justice b) enhancing the awareness and confidence of the public c) satisfying the victims by sentencing the criminals d) to redress the disproportionality among various races and e) recovery of stolen assets or properties3. As per recent research study carried over by academics at Birmingham University reveals that crime rates will tend to decline when there are tougher prison sentences and further there is a direct link between levels of policing activity and crime reduction . Hence, the study strongly suggests that UK government should desist from downsizing its police personnel, mainly on the grounds of cost cutting. The ab ove study found that prison imprisonment was especially successful in minimising the property crime by repeat and serious offenders in UK. It also found that if sentence is increased to 16.4 months from that of 15.4 months, it is likely to minimise the burglaries in the succeeding year by 4800 out of annual aggregate of 962,700. The report finds that there is unambiguous evidence that more effective and sustained policing will definitely minimise the crime rates in UK4. Burden of proof in criminal cases Under English criminal law , the most renowned cannon is that the accused will be treated as innocent until the prosecution proves the guilty of offence of an accused by beyond realistic doubt. Though the English law assumes an accused as an innocent, but it yet requires upon the prosecution to produce adequate evidence so that the court can declare the accused as an offender. The famous maxim as held in Hobson5 that one innocent man should not be punished even if ten guilty men coul d escape from the punishment. Earlier, in Woolmington v DPP, where defendant W claimed that he killed her wife accidentally. In that case, the court was of the view that defendant had the onus of proving any defence it which wanted to forward. However, the same was turned down by the House of Lords, and it held that, the prosecution had the onus of establishing all the components of crime except in some extraordinary cases, and it did not acknowledge any defences forwarded by the accused6. Thus, the ââ¬Å"golden thread ââ¬Å" rule which inflicts the whole legal onus on the prosecution, and the maxim that the Crown must establish its case beyond any satisfactory doubt was held in very old case namely 7White8. Thus, in Woolmington case9, the House of Lord set precedent by pronouncing that the prosecution assumes the whole onus in criminal cases. It is claimed that by placing the whole burden of proof on prosecution, it helps to minimise the wrongful convictions by police. It also de notes the severity of criminal convictions and thereby increases the moral convictions among the police. Thus, under English law, the prosecution is responsible for any of defences put forth by an accused like alibi, provocation, self-defence or duress. In Ashley v Chief Constable of Sussex Police,10 in criminal proceedings, the onus of negativing self-defence lies upon the prosec
Wednesday, February 5, 2020
Mitosis Essay Example | Topics and Well Written Essays - 250 words
Mitosis - Essay Example Animals for instance are known to undergo a form of mitosis called open mitosis. This is where the nuclear envelop disintegrates before the chromosomes separate. Fungi on the other hand are known to undergo a closed mitosis where the chromosomes divide within an unbroken cell nucleus (Golitsin and Krylov, 100-150). The process is divided into several stages and these are as a result of the different sequence of events that take place upon the completion of one activity to pave way for another. There are six stages in mitosis and these include interphase, prophase, prometaphase, metaphase, anaphase and lastly the telophase. During the process the pairs of chromatids shorten and attach to fibers which then pull the sister chromatids to the opposite ends of the cell. Cytokinesis then occurs to create two identical daughter cells (McAinsh, 100-330). Interphase: here the cell prepares for cell division by manufacturing proteins and cytoplasmic organelles. This phase is divided into three stages, first gap (G1), synthesis(S) and second gap (G2). The last second phase is where chromosomes replicate (McAinsh, 100-330).. Prophase: the chromatin shortens into a chromosome. Since at the S phase the genetic material duplicated, the replicated chromosomes have two sister chromatids that are bound together at the center. At this stage the centrosomes (coordinating center for a cell microtubules) are pushed to the opposite sides of the cell (McAinsh, 100-330). Prometaphase: the nuclei envelop disassembles and microtubules come in the nuclei space. Each chromosome then forms two kinetochores at the centromere and each one is attached at each chromatid (Snedden, 1-48). Metaphase: the two centrosomes begin pulling the chromosomes along their attached centromeres towards the end of the cells. The chromosomes become tensed from the longitudinal pull. The centromeres of the chromosomes align along the metaphase
Monday, January 27, 2020
Doctrine of Harmonious Construction
Doctrine of Harmonious Construction HISTORY 1st amendment came in the case of Sankari Prasad before SC. The court unanimously decided to resolve the conflict between Fundamental Rights and Directive Principles by placing the reliance of the line of doctrine of harmonious construction. The court held that the FRs impose limitation over the legislature and executive power. They are not inviolable and parliament can amend them to bring in conformity to directive principles. The result was generally all law providing for the acquisition of state and interest therein and specially certain state including land reform acts of U.P., Bihar and M.P. were immune from the attack based on article 13 read with other provision of part III. DOCRTINE OF HARMONIOUS CONSTRUCTION It is a sound canon of interpretation that courts must try to avoid a conflict between the provisions of Statute. The rule of reconciliation on the Entries was propounded for the first time in the case of in re C.P. and Bare Act. It is the province of the courts to determine the extent of the authority to deal with subjects falling within the legislative purview of each legislature. To avoid conflict, the Courts should read Entries of two Lists together and the language of one Entry can be interpreted, and modified too, with the help of another Entry. Interpreting Entries 24 and 25 of the State List harmoniously, the Supreme Court held that gas and gas works being in Entry 25 would not fall in the general Entry 24Industry and observed: It is also well settled that widest amplitude should be given to the language of Entries but some of the entries in the different Listsà ¢Ã¢â ¬Ã ¦may overlap and sometimes may also appear to be in direct conflict with each other, it is then duty of this court to reconcile the entries and bring about harmony between them. In this way it may, in most cases, be found possible to arrive at a reasonable and practical construction of the language of the sections, so as to reconcile the respective powers they contain and to give effect to all of them. In Tika Ramji v. State of Uttar Pradesh, [3] the position of the industries was clarified by Supreme Court. In the instant case the vires of U.P. Sugarcane (Regulation of Supply and Purchase) Act, 1953 was involved. It was contended that sugarcane being controlled industry fall within the jurisdiction of the Union List by virtue of Entry 52 of List I falls within the legislative purview of Parliament. The Supreme Court, therefore, had to e xplain the Inter-relation between Entries 52 of List I, 24 and 27 of List II and 33 of List III. Entry 24 of List II and 52 of List I establish that except controlled industries, the industries generally fells within the State Sphere. Entry 27 of List II gives power to State to regulate the production, supply and distribution of goods subject to provisions of Entry 33 of List III. The sugar industry being controlled industry, the distribution, supply and production of the product of this controlled industry viz. Sugar as a finished product, Principle of Harmonious Construction The principle of harmonious interpretation is similar to the idea of broad or purposive approach. The key to this method of constitutional interpretation is that provisions of the Constitution should be harmoniously interpreted. Constitutional provisions should not be construed in isolation from all other parts of the Constitution, but should be construed as to harmonize with those other parts. A provision of the constitution must be construed and considered as part of the Constitution and it should be given a meaning and an application which does not lead to conflict with other Articles and which confirms with the Constitutions general scheme. When there are two provisions in a statute, which are in apparent conflict with each other, they should be interpreted such that effect can be given to both and that construction which renders either of them inoperative and useless should not be adopted except in the last resort. This principle is illustrated in the case of Raj Krishna vs Bino d AIR 1954. In this case, two provisions of Representation of People Act, 1951, which were in apparent conflict were brought forth. Section 33 (2) says that a Government Servant can nominate or second a person in election but section 123(8) says that a Government Servant cannot assist any candidate in election except by casting his vote. The Supreme Court observed that both these provisions should be harmoniously interpreted and held that a Government Servant was entitled to nominate or second a candidate seeking election in State Legislative assembly. This harmony can only be achieved if Section 123(8) is interpreted as giving the govt. servant the right to vote as well as to nominate or second a candidate and forbidding him to assist the candidate it any other manner. Upon looking at various cases, the following important aspects of this principle are evident The courts must avoid a head on clash of seemingly contradicting provisions and they must construe the contradictory provi sions so as to harmonize them. The provision of one section cannot be used to defeat the provision contained in another unless the court, despite all its effort, is unable to find a way to reconcile their differences. When it is impossible to completely reconcile the differences in contradictory provisions, the courts must interpret them in such as way so that effect is given to both the provisions as much as possible. Courts must also keep in mind that interpretation that reduces one provision to a useless number or a dead lumbar, is not harmonious construction. To harmonize is not to destroy any statutory provision or to render it otiose. Case 1: Unni Krishnan, J.P. and ors., etc. v. State of Andhra Pradesh and ors. The writ petition was filed challenging whether the right to life under Article 21 of the constitution guarantees a fundamental right to education to the citizens of India and right to education includes professional education. This was challenged by certain private professional educational institutions and also in respect of regulating capitation fees charged by such institutions. The Supreme Court held that right to basic education was implied by the fundamental right to life when read with article 41 of directive principle on education. As per article 45 of the constitution, the state is to provide free and compulsory education for all children below the age of 14 years and there is no fundamental right to education for a professional degree that flows from article 21. Several states have passed legislation making primary education compulsory and there is no central legislation to make elementary education compulsory. In addition, the Court held that, in order to treat a right as fundamental right, it is not necessary that it should be expressly stated as one in Part III of the Constitution: the provisions of Part III and Part IV are supplementary and complementary to each other. The Court rejected that the rights reflected in the provisions of Part III are superior to the moral claims and aspirations reflected in the provisions of Part IV. Case:2 Smt. Rani Kusum vs Smt. Kanchan Devi And Ors on 16 August, 2005 Showing the contexts in which harmonious construction author:A Pasayat appears in the document have to ascertain the object which is required to be served by this provision and its design and context in which it is enacted. The use of the word shall is ordinarily indicative of mandatory nature of the provision but having regard to the context in which it is used or having regard to the intention of the legislation, the same can be construed as directory. The rule in question has to advance the cause of justice and not to defeat it. The rules of procedure are made to advance the cause of justice and not to defeat it. Construction of the rule or procedure which promotes justice and prevents miscarriage has to be preferred. The rules or procedure are handmaid of justice stress. In the present context, the strict interpretation would defeat justice. In construing this provision, support can also be had from Order VIII Rule 10 which provides that where any party from whom a written statement is required under Rule 1 or Rule 9, fails to present the same within the time permitted or fixed by the Court, the Court shall pronounce judgment against him, or make such other order in relation written statement under this provision, the Court has been given the discretion either to pronounce judgment against the defendant or make such other order in relation to suit as it thinks fit. In the context of the provision, despite use of the word shall, the court has been given the discretion to pronounce or not to pronounce the judgment against the defendant even if written statement is not filed and instead pass such order as it may think fit in relation to the suit. In construing the provision of Order VIII Rule 1 and Rule 10, the doctrine of harmonious construction is required to be applied. The effect would be that under Rule 10 of Order VII I, the court in its discretion would have power to allow the defendant to file written statement even after expiry of period of 90 days provided in Order VIII Rule 1. There is no restriction in Order VIII Rule 10 that after expiry of ninety days, further time cannot be granted. The Court has wide power to make such order in relation to the suit as it thinks fit. Clearly, therefore, the provision of Order VIII Rule 1 providing for upper limit State Of Orissa And Ors vs Arakhita Bisoi on 14 April, 1977 Showing the contexts in which harmonious construction appears in the document respondent was allowed by the Orissa High Court by its order dated 15-7-1976 holding that the Additional Magistrate had powers to revise an order of the appellate authority passed u/s 44 by virtue of the powers conferred on him under s. 59of the Act. Dismissing the appeal by certificate, the Court, HELD: (i)The language of S. 59(1) of the Orissa Land Reforms Act is wide enough to enable the Collector to revise any order including an appellate order under S. 44 of the Act.[561B] (ii) In applying the rule of harmonious construction with a view to give effect to the intention of the legislature the court will not be justified in putting a construction which would restrict the revisionary jurisdiction of the Collector and the Board of Revenue. [560E] In the instant case, the Act is of expropratory nature and the determination of the excess lands is done by the Revenue Officer. The legislature intended that any error or irregularity should be rectified by higher authorities like the Collector and the Board of Revenue. [560E] J. K. Cotton Spinning Weaving Mills Co. Ltd. v. State revise such order. Though the amendment to section 44(3) makes it clear that a right to revision is provided for orders passed under section 44(2), we do not think that this could mean that section 44(2) as it originally stood did not provide for power of revision to the Collector under section59. In our opinion, amendment does not make any difference. The learned counsel for the appella nt submitted that section 44(3) is in the nature of a special provision and should be construed as an exception to section 59 on the principle of harmonious construction. In support of this plea the learned counsel referred to the decision in The J.K. Cotton Spinning Weaving Mills Co. Ltd. v. State of U.P. Ors. (1). In construing the provisions of clause 5(a) and clause 23 of the G.O. concerned, this Court held that the rule of harmonious construction should be applied and in applying the rule the court will have to remember that to harmonise is not to destroy and that in interpreting the statutes the court always presumes that the legislature inserted every part thereof for a purpose and the legislative intention is that every part of the statute should have effect, and a construction which defeats the intention of the rule-making authority must be avoided. This decision does not help the appellant for in our view in applying the rule of harmonious construction with a view to giv e effect to the intention o(the legislature the court will not be justified in putting a construction which would restrict the revisionary jurisdiction of the Collector and the Board of Revenue. It may be noted that the Act is of exproprietory nature and the determination of the excess lands is done by the Revenue Officer and on appeal by the Revenue Divisional Officer. In such circumstances, it is only 13roper to presume that the legislature intended that any error or irregularity should be rectified by higher authorities like the Collector and the Board of Revenue. In our view it will be in conformity with the intention of the legislature to hold that section 59 confers a power of revision of an order passed under section 44(2) of the Act. The learned counsel next referred to a decision of this Court in The Bengal Immunity Company Limited rule of construction is stated at p. 791 in the following terms by Venkatarama Ayyar, J. speaking for the Court: It is a cardinal rule of constr uction that when there are in a Statute two provisions which are in conflict with each other such that both of them cannot stand, they should, if possible be so interpreted that effect can be given to both, and that a construction which renders either of them inoperative and useless should not be adopted except in the last resort. This is what is known as the rule of harmonious construction. One application of this rule is that when there 561 is a law generally dealing with a subject and another dealing particularly with one of the topics comprised therein, the general law is to be construed as yielding to the special in respect of the matters comprised therein. Construing section 59 as conferring a power of revision against an order passed under section 44(2) is not in any way contrary to the principle laid down in the above decision. Jagdish Singh vs Lt. Governor Delhi And Others on 11 March, 1997 Showing the contexts in which harmonious construction appears in the document later. The Registrar, however, committed serious error in interpreting Sub-rule (2) of Rule 25 and directing cessation of membership of the appellant from both the societies. Mr. Bobde also argued that if Sub-rule (2) of Rule 25 is interpreted to mean that on incurring such disqualification by operation of law one ceases to be a member of both societies, then Rule 28 conferring power on the Registrar to give a written requisition to either or both the co-operative societies for cessation of the membership, would become inoperative, and therefore, efforts should be made for harmonious construction where under both the provisions can operate. Mr. Bobde also argued that under Rule 25(1) the embargo upon a person to become a member of a co-operative society is there if the said person or his spouse or any of his dependent children is a member of any other housing society. The disqualification in question is thu s attached to becoming a member of co-operative society if he is already a member of another society. Under Sub-rule (2) of Rule 25 a deemed cessation accrues obviously in relation to a society in respect of which the disqualification is attached question that arises for consideration is: whether a person who is a member of a housing co-operative society having incurred the disqualification under Rule 25(1)(c)(iii) on being a member of a subsequent housing society would cease to be a member of both the societies with effect from the date of the disqualification incurred by him. It is a cardinal principal of construction of a statute or the statutory rule that efforts should be made in construing the different provisions, so that, each provision will have its play and in the event of any conflict a harmonious construction should be given. Further a statute or a rule made there under should be read as a whole and one provision should be construed with reference to the other provision so as to make the rule consistent and any construction which would bring any inconsistency or repugnancy between one provision and the other should be avoided. One rule cannot be used to defeat another rule in the same rules unless it is impossible to effect harmonisation between them. The well-known principle of harmonious construction is that effect should be given to all the provisions, and therefore, this Court held in several cases that a construction that reduces one of the provisions to a dead letter is not a harmonious construction as one part is being destroyed and consequently court should avoid such a construction. Bearing in mind the aforesaid rules of construction if Sub-rule (2) of Rule 25 and Rule 28 are examined the obvious answer would be that under Sub-rule (2) the deemed cessation from membership of the person concerned is in relation to the society pertaining to which disqualifications are incurred. A plain reading of Rule 28 makes it crystal clear that the Regis trar when becomes aware of the fact that an individual has become a member of two co-operative societies of the same class which obviously is a disqualification under Rule 25 then he has the discretion to direct removal of the said individual from the membership of either or both the co-operative societies. If Sub-rule (2) of Rule 25 is interpreted to mean that deemed cessation of the person concerned from membership of both the societies then the question of discretion of the Registrar under Rule 28 will not arise .If the interpretation given by the Registrar incurred. In the case in hand the disqualification which the appellant incurred was in respect of his membership of the Tribal Co-operative Housing Society Ltd. as he could not have become a member of the said society as he was already a member of Dronacharaya Co-operative Group Housing Society, and therefore, by operation of Sub-rule (2) he would deem to have ceased to be a member from the Tribal Co-operative Housing Society right from the inception in November, 1983 and not from the Dronacharaya Co- operative Group Housing Society. 8. Apart from the aforesaid harmonious construction of Sub-rule (2) of Rule 25 and Rule 28, on a plain construction of Rules 25 also the same conclusion has to be arrived at. Sub-rule (1) disqualifies a person for admission as member of a housing society if he or his spouse or any of his dependent children is a member of any other housing society. The disqualification in question obviously attaches to membership of the second society and has no connection with his membership of the first society. In view of the aforesaid embargo contained in Sub-rule (1) to Rule 25, Sub-rule Significance The courts must avoid a head on clash of seemingly contradicting provisions and they must construe the contradictory provisions so as to harmonize them. The provision of one section cannot be used to defeat the provision contained in another unless the court, despite all its effort, is unable to find a way to reconcile their differences. When it is immpossible to completely reconcile the differences in contradictory provisions, the courts must interpret them in such as way so that effect is given to both the provisions as much as possible. Courts must also keep in mind that interpretation that reduces one provision to a useless number or a dead lumbar, is not harmonious construction. To harmonize is not to destroy any statutory provision or to render it otiose. Conclusion As per this doctrine the courts must try to avoid conflicts between the provisions of the statutes. Thus the provisions must be so interpreted that the conflict between the two is avoided and each of them is given effect and, for that purpose the scope and meaning of one may be restricted so as to give meaning to the other also.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)